USAID’s Eventful Week at the World Bank Land Conference 2024

After a four-year hiatus, the World Bank resumed its annual Land Conference in Washington, DC. Attendees from around the world convened in mid-May to connect and learn about innovations in the international land sector. 

USAID was busy throughout the week: USAID’s Chief Climate Officer Gillian Caldwell spoke on a panel on forest tenure and Indigenous Peoples, while members of the Land and Resource Governance (LRG) Division organized a session on the green energy transition and also took part in conversations on global land policies, women’s land rights, and climate adaptation. The LRG team also held “booth talks” in the Bank’s atrium, chatting with other conference attendees on a number of topics, including participatory land mapping, critical minerals, impact evaluations, and women’s land rights

Staff from several USAID activities also participated in the conference. The Integrated Natural Resource Management activity presented its recent report, Tanzania Demand for Documentation Study, and the Integrated Land and Resource Governance II activity facilitated three panels focused on 1) cross-ministry coordination for land policy implementation; 2) land administration challenges amid climate change; and 3) innovative approaches to unlock rural and Indigenous women’s land rights.

Post-conference, members of the LRG Division shared some of their key takeaways from the week. Much of the team’s reflections center on climate change or Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLCs). Both intersectional issues are ongoing priorities that help frame the LRG Division’s research and programming. In fact, land and resource governance is a prominent theme in USAID’s 2022-2030 Climate Strategy, as well as in the Agency’s 2020 Policy on Promoting the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (PRO-IP), Local Capacity Strengthening Policy, and Rule of Law Policy. That’s because investing in land rights is critical for achieving positive development outcomes for IPLCs—including economic growth, empowerment, and biodiversity conservation—and is also necessary for achieving climate mitigation outcomes.

Check out some of the team’s thoughts below!

Karol Boudreaux, Senior Land and Resource Governance Advisor

A helpful takeaway came from David Kaimowitz’s work at the Tenure Facility, where they are supporting communities to rent (i.e., contract out) land mapping equipment to local governments and also to  create Memoranda of Understanding (MOUs) with governments to work as land service providers. Control of land and resources is associated with significant political, social, and economic power, and in a number of countries the rights of local communities to their land are impinged by government actors and their economic allies. This is an interesting way to “flip the script” and put local communities and governments in a somewhat different relationship, with altered power dynamics and information sharing.

Ioana Bouvier, Senior Spatial Science and Technology Advisor

Many land-intensive climate action initiatives, including carbon offsetting projects, have yet to recognize the role of land rights and the importance of engaging local communities from initial stages of the project. Land practitioners should be more actively engaged in the climate mitigation sector, including climate finance. Ruth Meinzen-Dick and Steven Lawry led a very compelling session on the concept of community stewardship and the importance of ensuring that local communities actively take part in the decisions about how land is managed in climate action projects.

Janet Nackoney, Land and Resource Governance Officer

There were several thoughtful presentations and discussions around social inclusion and gender, including those focused on gender norms change. Safiatu Alabi from Côte d’Ivoire spoke about the importance of understanding the delicate balance between social norms and cultural values when engaging in norms change programming. She stressed the importance of respecting the underlying socio-cultural values held by local communities when carrying out social norms change activities, so that these values are preserved. Safiatu highlighted how practitioners can work with communities to facilitate uptake of new social norms by building a collective vision that recognizes potential positive outcomes resulting from norms change interventions. Conversations also centered on the importance of engaging men and boys to support and actively promote gender equality and focusing on interventions that increase women’s economic empowerment to ensure that women can access markets, have greater control over resources, and participate in economic decision-making.

Caleb Stevens, Senior Advisor, Governance and Natural Environment

The Smithsonian and Conservation International are conducting cutting-edge research demonstrating that secure property rights for Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities across South America significantly reduces deforestation, and that the bundle of rights that provide “ownership” is particularly important. Those are promising findings, but IPLCs need more support: Despite the proven ability of Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities to conserve biodiversity and reduce deforestation, and despite the fact that Indigenous and locally-owned land is profoundly affected by climate change, their lack of secure and documented land rights globally often leads to their exclusion from natural resource management decision-making processes. 

Chloe Cole, Natural Resources Officer

The land community can be louder and do more to define the narrative around the land tenure implications of the green energy transition, which includes the land needed for mining and technology deployment. Joan Carling from Indigenous Peoples Rights International spoke a lot about community co-ownership, equity sharing, and allowing for Indigenous voices. I think there’s a lot of work that the international land sector can do to fill in the details around Indigenous rights. What does that look like in regard to mining, solar energy, and other climate initiatives?

Land Cover Mapping Leads Nepal’s Climate Action Strategy Through Data Innovation

Cross-posted from SERVIR

When countries need to make sustainable decisions about how best to use their land, they need highly detailed and current information—but accurately measuring how much of a country is forested or not (including land used for farming or undergoing urban expansion) can be incredibly difficult. More and more countries like Nepal are using satellite technology to address this challenge and create their own land monitoring systems.

Nepal’s National Land Cover Monitoring System (NLCMS) represents a pivotal achievement and is poised to significantly enhance the country’s climate data and efforts to cut emissions and adapt to climate change. This system holds immense importance for assessing and overseeing the ever-changing landscape, which is crucial for the sustainable stewardship of Nepal’s natural resources.

Nepal Land cover monitoring system. An animated version of this map is available on the original blog post (linked at top of this page). Credit: SERVIR HKH

Since 2018, SERVIR HKH has been continuously collaborating with Nepal’s Forest Research and Training Centre (FRTC), the nationally mandated agency for forest cover data, to develop an operational NLCMS for Nepal.

The NLCMS uses publicly available satellite imagery like Landsat combined with robust methodologies to regularly generate annual land cover data for the entire country. Data from the land cover map, which includes the forest cover extent, is used to generate estimations of land-based greenhouse gas emissions from forest loss.

Why land data matters to Nepal

FRTC uses the land cover maps for national and international reporting on forest cover change and preparing a long-term strategy for achieving Nepal’s Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) targets for addressing climate change. It also serves as a foundational dataset to advance evidence-based planning and policy development.

The NLCMS addresses the challenges of long-term data gaps by providing consistent geospatial data crucial for various sectors such as forestry, climate action, and research. NLCMS data played a pivotal role in setting climate targets for Nepal’s commitments to the Paris Agreement and is being extensively used in forest degradation mapping, climate change action, and academic research.

Bimal Kumar Acharya, Senior Remote Sensing Officer from FRTC states, “The NLCMS results are useful in the planning and policy-making processes of Nepal’s federal, provincial, and local governments. It is also useful for reporting on Nepal’s national and international obligations.”

NLCMS land cover data has become the national data to help the government and members of civil society to understand the geographic distribution of different land cover types present in Nepal. The Government of Nepal, through FRTC, has adopted this system, establishing it as a credible and authentic data source for official use. The National Statistics Office uses the data and map for generating land cover statistics for international reporting, such as for the Second NDC, which was developed based on this data.

Collaboration for success and sustainability

Continuous capacity strengthening with relevant stakeholders in Nepal has been critical to the success and final endorsement and implementation of the NLCMS. The partners in Nepal have invested time and personal resources to efficiently contribute and co-develop the system and  advance a sustainable pathway for the NLCMS to be an essential platform for years to come.

Computing resources and expertise from SERVIR’s Applied Sciences Team member Peter Potapov from the University of Maryland significantly enhanced the value of the land cover map through the incorporation of Tree Canopy Cover, Tree Canopy Height, and various other data layers. These additional datasets have played a pivotal role in improving the overall accuracy and precision of the data included in the NLCMS.

“Our approach to co-developing the NLCMS product by partnering with the National Agency (FRTC) and Applied Science Team (University of Maryland) brought cutting-edge technologies and built the capacity and confidence of national stakeholders on the use of the new mapping method and the land cover data. The web-based, easy-to-use interface of the product is built utilizing a cloud processing platform and openly available time series satellite images, making the product efficient and replicable relatively easily at significantly low costs for any country annually anywhere in the world, ensuring the sustainability for the longer term.” – Rajesh Bahadur Thapa, Science and Data Lead, SERVIR-HKH

An Incentive for Illicit Crop Substitution: Land Rights

A USAID partnership is enabling the Colombian Government to move forward with its commitments to formalize land and reduce illicit crops.

a group of people holding up a land ownership documentWith USAID support, Colombia’s National Land Agency delivered 83 land titles to families who have voluntarily substituted illicit crops in the municipality of Cáceres, Antioquia. The property titles correspond to over 1,200 hectares of rural land in the heart of Bajo Cauca, a zone affected by years of violence and narcotrafficking.

The land titles were delivered this year during the visit of US Director of National Drug Control Policy, Dr. Rahul Gupta. Before meeting landowners who have substituted illicit crops in exchange for land titles, Gupta joined government officials and the US Ambassador to Colombia, Francisco Palmieri, to fly over the region and see how illicit crop cultivation and illegal mining have affected the area.

“I want to express congratulations to these families who became proud owners of their land parcels. The families here today deserve to own their land in order to work on it and build a life where they can leave illicit crops behind. This is proof that rural development works, and should continue to be part of our holistic strategy.”

Transformation in Rural Colombia

a man smiling and holding his land titleSecure land tenure is the backbone of an innovative strategy aligned with Colombia’s new drug policy to encourage the voluntary substitution of illicit crops in exchange for land titling and a package of targeted support that includes food security provisions and investments in agriculture and infrastructure projects to promote territorial transformation.

Helping rural communities replace illicit crops with legal alternatives, increasing rural development, and supporting their transition to participate in formal markets instead of depending on illicit economies, is a pillar of Colombia’s new drug policy.

It is a pleasure that finally a drug policy is not only about security, right? It is also about access to land and the vindication of the rights of our campesinos.” says Gloria Miranda, Director of Colombia’s coca substitution program

The Colombian government has already delivered over 600 land titles in Cáceres, and 150 of those are in the names of families who once grew illicit crops. Thanks to USAID support, the government is poised to deliver more than 1,300 land titles over the next year in Cáceres.

Securing Land Rights

The increase in legal land ownership is the direct result of the implementation of rural property and land use plans, known by their Spanish acronym, POSPR. In Cáceres, implementation took place over 18 months and surveyed more than 5,600 rural parcels. The POSPR efforts coordinated with the Colombian government to successfully clear landmines from over 100,000 hectares of the north of the municipality, updated the Cáceres’ rural and urban cadaster, and strengthened the presence of a Municipal Land Office.

The success of the approach hinges on the support of municipal leaders and the communities, including hundreds of social leaders whose local knowledge is fundamental. These social leaders ensure women are active participants in the process, and the National Land Agency ensures women’s land rights are recognized by issuing joint land titles for properties owned by two people.

Since 2020, USAID is supporting the National Land Agency with POSPR implementation in 11 municipalities across Colombia. In five of those municipalities, there is a presence of illicit crops, as well as minefields and illegal armed groups.

“What we are achieving in Caceres, we must achieve throughout the country so that the farmers have the peace of mind that they have a plot of land for their children,
– Felipe Harman, Director of the National Land Agency

To complement the rural land formalization initiative in Cáceres, government entities like the Ministry of Justice are partnering with the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime to provide food security relief and mobilize funds for key infrastructure projects, such as bridges.

“Cultivating life is access to land, it is an agrarian reform, it means the person who has depended on growing coca can have a dignified life, a sustainable life project that allows them to have access and not be subjected to violence,” says Gloria.

Cross-posted from USAID Exposure

Reclaiming the Rights to Land of Rural Women

USAID is supporting initiatives in Southern Tolima for rural women to understand and reclaim their rights to land

2 women sitting at a table looking at a laptopAs part of the Rural Property and Land Administration Plan (POSPR) being implemented in Chaparral, USAID Land for Prosperity (LFP) partnered with Colombia’s Land Restitution Unit to host a series of workshops to empower rural women about their property rights, land ownership, the care economy, and gender-based violence. These workshops, called nucleos de exigibilidad, were piloted first in Ataco during POSPR implementation. During the sessions, 30 female leaders who are participating in land restitution and formalization processes shared their views of their territory and learned about gender-based violence with a focus on patrimonial and economic violence. The women met three times to discuss crucial topics for their personal growth and the one of their communities, as an opportunity to strengthen their leadership and promote gender equality in Southern Tolima.

Social, indigenous, afro-Colombian, and farmer leaders participated alongside presidents of community action boards and victims of the armed conflict. Some of them are beneficiaries of the POSPR implementation and others are in land restitution processes. These neighbors, although they share similar experiences and complex realities, had never met to talk.

two people standing on top of a hillThe strategy was originally implemented in the municipality of Ataco and was recently extended to Chaparral, with the aim of building the capacity of these women so they can multiply their knowledge with their communities and neighborhoods. The work between the URT and LFP coordinates two important public policies: the one for rural property and land administration, and the one for land restitution.

“All exercises were focused on highlighting the role of women in society and identifying the different types of violence that women face. It was an opportunity to be clear about the relationship and the rights that women have to land,” says Héctor Canal, territorial director of the URT.

Advancing together towards our rights

a group of women standing around a craft tableThe participants showed an unbreakable commitment in this process, becoming agents of change in their communities. Edna Liliana Castro, resident of the Guanábano Brasilia village, has stood out not just as a farmer but also as an influential leader, playing a valuable role in the implementation of the POSPR as a community volunteer. Community volunteers are vital, as they encourage the communities to participate, and disseminate the POSPR methodology and objectives so that people understand the benefits of titling their land.

Their involvement in the workshops was vital to strengthen their leadership in a community with a difficult history: “As social leaders in a rural community, unfortunately we are very forgotten. Peasant and rural women have always been forgotten. We weren’t very clear about our own rights, but in these spaces they taught us in a dynamic way, so we can share this knowledge with our communities, demanding the priority and value that women have.”

Edna also mentioned that the events strengthened the leadership of these women, regardless of their age: “During the workshops, women from different ages came together, from teenagers to senior citizens. Despite the age difference, we managed to build deep connections and mutual understanding, creating bonds that were so strong that we felt like a real family.”

Alcyra Carreño, resident of the urban area of Chaparral, said that the workshops allowed her to recognize the value of her own body as a temple, just like the action of claiming equal rights between men and women when it comes to land: “I would like for us women to become land and property owners. I have my small farm, but I don’t have a formal document that recognizes me as an owner, even though I work the land with my son.”

The last session of the workshops coincided with International Women’s Day, and during the event the women held a discussion with public officials from government entities such as the Agency for Rural Development, the Rural Development and the Community Development and Health Municipal Secretaries, and the Municipal Council. The women were grateful for the opportunity to advocate and take action in favor of their rights, both in rural and urban environments.

“These events help us understand that us women can continue fighting for our rights, and that it is important for many women to feel supported, as we are the core of our families and communities.

Cross-posted from USAID Exposure

Formalizing Land Through Corporate Social Responsibility

USAID is working with Colombia’s private sector to formalize land and mobilize funds to improve schools and other services.

a bar graph detailing the Land Informality Rates in Bajo Cauca (2019)
Land Informality Rates in Bajo Cauca (2019)

In 2020, when Antioquia’s Secretary of Education unveiled an investment plan to improve the infrastructure of rural public schools and increase attendance rates, the project quickly came to a halt, because the government is not allowed to inject public funds into assets and services on land without a registered land title. All over Antioquia, hundreds of isolated schools have been built on open land, on properties donated by large landowners, or simply on land that never belonged to anyone.

Without a land title, these schools continue to deteriorate and miss out on much-needed public funds.

Formalizing land in Colombia is a long and costly process that involves several government agencies. Rural families who can afford the costs of processing a land title, including lawyer and land surveyor fees, often end up waiting five years or longer for a land title. Relying on local and regional governments, which are cash-strapped or lack technical capacity, is even more unlikely to result in a registered land title.

In Bajo Cauca, one of Antioquia’s poorest regions, land informality rates are some of the highest in Colombia.

What if the private sector destined social development investment towards land tenure security?

Historically, large companies have been wary about getting involved in land issues for fear of appearing to be associated with land grabbing or forced displacement. In the rural areas where investments are most needed, mining, energy, and construction firms prefer to avoid risky security situations and the complex histories related to the armed conflict. Instead, companies aim corporate social responsibility (CSR) investments at economic development, generating employment, or improving healthcare, particularly after the COVID-19 pandemic.

Alexandra Peláez stands posted next to a sign that reads "ProAntioquia"Land is a technical topic that is difficult to grasp. Companies may not understand the role of the many government agencies involved or why it is so time-consuming.” says Alexandra Peláez, Director of Education for Culture at ProAntioquia.

In the wake of the 2016 Peace Accords, CSR projects are beginning to recognize secure land tenure as the first step and foundation of rural development. Still, according to ProAntioquia, only 1% of the COP $2.9 billion (USD $1 million) invested by private companies every year in social projects goes towards land formalization.

“The performance indicators are not very attractive either. Due to being such a slow process of creating, and completing cases in order to deliver land titles, it’s not easy to tell a board of directors that they invested money to legalize a case,” according to Pelaéz.

Changing the Paradigm

The privately operated foundation ProAntioquia–which is made up of some of the largest companies in Colombia including Grupo Sura, Argos, Bancolombia, and Nutresa–has spent over 50 years promoting sustainable economic development in the department of Antioquia.

Carlos Lopera stands with another man, both of them holding a certificate.
Carlos Lopera (right) delivering a land title to a beneficiary.

In 2020, USAID Land for Prosperity partnered with ProAntioquia to draw more attention to land issues and raise awareness among its members that by investing in projects that secure land tenure, the private sector could make a social impact, contribute to the goals of the 2016 Peace Accords, and improve the quality of life of rural communities.

Together, USAID and ProAntioquia looked at more than 500 public properties in Antioquia’s Bajo Cauca region and mobilized COP $847 million (USD $300,000) to title as many properties as possible. ProAntioquia contributed 18% of the total investment, directing funds towards the hiring of a legal expert and land surveyor to fast-track initial property analyses. The team visited 318 parcels, some of which are only accessible by foot or on horseback.

To date, 70 public properties have received registered land titles in six municipalities. The properties correspond to 56 schools, 10 community centers, and four sports facilities.

Ituango’s Secretary of Education and Culture, Leidy Vargas, worked with the teams to identify schools in Ituango, a storied municipality that was occupied by anti-government rebels for years. USAID and ProAntioquia’s support allowed the government to title 15 rural properties in Ituango.

“Secure tenure opens the door to many opportunities in rural development and allows the government to access parts of the municipality that public servants had not seen in over two decades,” Vargas said. Now that these public parcels are formalized, public and private actors can invest to improve them. Last year, the municipal administration of Ituango mobilized COP $300 million (more than USD $100,000) in funds to improve infrastructure and purchase equipment for four rural schools that provide an education for over 225 children.

“These properties may be small in size, but these land titles empower the communities and are a symbol of peace,” says Carlos Lopera, who worked as Antioquia’s regional manager for the National Land Agency during the project.

Engaging the Private Sector

a group of schoolchildren walk in a line Despite the success, convincing the private sector to invest in rural land formalization remains a monumental challenge. Land for Prosperity examined the landscape by looking at nearly 2,000 companies in its eight target regions, and then narrowed down the list to 164 potential partners. A total of 77 companies replied to the proposal and engaged in dialogues and presentations on the subject.

In the end, Land for Prosperity drafted work proposals for five private organizations, but only two projects materialized: ProAntioquia in Bajo Cauca and the National Federation of Coffee Growers, whose investments supported the formalization of 300 coffee farms in rural Cauca.

The partnerships between the private sector and USAID have enormous potential to promote land formalization and rural development. The combination of the private sector’s experience with rapid project execution and supervision and USAID’s ability to coordinate and align government actors and communities, increases the chances for success and generates trust among partners.

“In a country like Colombia, where there are so many unmet basic needs, like sewage, roads, health, education, and malnutrition, one can get lost with what issues to resolve. This partnership between ProAntioquia and USAID has put the issue of land tenure on the public agenda.”
– Alexandra Peláez, ProAntioquia.

Cross-posted from USAID Exposure

“The world is dressing up in diversity.”

two men sit on a motorbikeInterview with a same-sex couple who requested a joint title to formalize their property in Chaparral, Tolima.

Challenging prejudices and building a more equal future where differences are respected, Mauro Julián Sánchez and Nelson Fabián Solano, a gay couple who requested the joint title of their rural parcel in Chaparral, Tolima, share their experience as part of the implementation of the Rural Property and Land Administration Plan (POSPR) led by the National Land Agency with support from the USAID Land for Prosperity Activity. To date, the large-scale land formalization initiative in Chaparral has resulted in three joint title applications that benefit same sex couples.

a man outside working on a houseWhat is the story of your parcel and how did you purchase it?

Mauro: We each lived in our parents’ house, but we wanted to have a joint parcel, something that belonged to both of us. We decided to buy a parcel to have something that was ours. However, we still don’t have the registered property title to our name. The parcel is two hectares and we work on it with our parents. We grow cassava, plantain and cacao in an organic way, without chemicals, to take care of the environment. We are also dabbling in aquaculture, creating ponds for fish farming.

What was your motivation to submit the joint title application to the National Land Agency?

Nelson: We are the kind of couple that is not common, that sometimes is frowned upon in some rural areas, but we are breaking stereotypes, which is beautiful. We have to start teaching communities that the world is dressing up in diversity. Our motivation is to make sure diversity is understood and respected, specifically when it comes to land formalization and access.

What does it mean to you to have your land titled as a same sex couple?

2 men sit with a woman typing on her computerMauro: It means a lot to us. In rural areas, homosexuality is sometimes negatively perceived, but our idea is to settle down and to be economically stable in the countryside. We want to access benefits such as loans to continue expanding our productive project and become a business. We want to be role models, show the community that the countryside can be profitable not just through production, but also through transformation. We don’t want to be seen just through discriminatory eyes, we want to show that we are capable of doing things better than a straight couple.

Do you think this process highlights the importance of a gender and inclusion approach for the LGBTIQ+ community when it comes to land access?

Nelson: The inclusion of every person, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity, is fundamental to guarantee equality and respect for the rights under land use planning and administration. We participated in a registration session to promote the inclusion of the LGBTIQ+ population in the formalization process, as part of the implementation of the government’s agrarian reform outlined in the Peace Accords.

What would you say to other same sex couples that are considering applying for joint titling?

a family sits with a man typing on his computerMauro: We want to tell them that, regardless of differences, as same sex couples we have the same rights and abilities. We should work together and show the world that homosexuality is not something out of the ordinary. Submitting an application for joint titling is a way to confirm our equality, to give visibility and promote the acceptance of diversity by the wider society, when it comes to land access.

Do you think that improved access to land and property rights helps close existing inequality gaps and reduce gender-based violence?

Nelson: Yes, access to land is an opportunity to close inequality gaps in the life projects of same sex couples. It gives us access to resources and projects offered by regional government entities, providing us with more development and improvement possibilities. We want to change the perception that some people have of us, and show society that we can achieve our goals, overcoming the obstacles that limit our objectives.

What does land mean to the LGBTIQ+ community?

Mauro: Land has an important meaning, especially for us, as we have our roots in this area that was hard hit by the conflict. Access to land means food security. Land is life, it is our origin and our destiny. From land we receive everything we need as human beings. That is why we have to work hard for its conservation, recognizing the value and respect we owe it.

A Neighbor Worth Trusting

Social leaders in Colombia are supporting rural women and promoting property formalization.

Yudy JiménezWhen Yudy Jiménez divorced her husband three years ago, she did not know the “rules of the game.” The couple, who was married for over 14 years, tried to divide their assets: her ex-husband kept the farm, and she kept the house.

But this year when she went to title her property with Colombia’s National Land Agency, her ex-husband tried to request a joint title. Yudy is a 33-year old mother with five children and lives in El Limón, a village of the municipality of Chaparral, in Tolima.

“The topographers came to measure my parcel, and he came to say this was also his. It was not fair, because he had kept the farm and had already sold it,” explained Yudy.

The land surveyors were working for a large-scale land formalization initiative being implemented across the municipality by USAID under direction from the National Land Agency. Fortunately for Yudy, the land surveyors were accompanied by experts in alternative dispute resolution (ADR), social workers who mediate land and property-related conflicts through arbitration, negotiation, and conciliation as an alternative to legal processes. The majority of these types of conflicts are between family members

a house with lots of plants hanging on the outside wall With the presence of social workers, Yudy felt supported as a single mother and as the owner of her parcel, and despite the pressure of her ex-husband, she completed the application to receive her property title in her name.

“Knowing that I will have a title to my property is a blessing. That I am a landowner and that I can continue building without being evicted is a legacy that I want to leave to my children,” she said.

Community Leaders

After that experience, Yudy wanted to play a more active role to make sure other women in Chaparral did not have to go through similar injustices. She found the opportunity to do it as a community volunteer supporting the implementation of the Rural Property and Land Administration Plan (POSPR), the official name of the government’s efforts to increase land formality in her municipality

Throughout the implementation of the POSPR in Chaparral, technical teams visited most of the 10,400 parcels in the municipality. In many cases, these visits involve talking with and collecting information from the owners of the parcel. In order to do this, a network of more than 230 community volunteers act as a liaison between the community and the team of professionals. Almost half of the volunteers were women.

The volunteers learned about conflicts related to land use and tenure, a differential approach to land ownership, as well as environmental and legal restrictions on land use and ownership.

a group of volunteers sit listening to their instructorIn her role as a community volunteer, Yudy helped to identify conflicts like the one she had with her ex-husband. “I remember when a couple fought because the husband wanted to apply for individual titling. I was there to teach them about the care economy and the women’s rights to joint land titling,” said Yudy.

USAID trained the volunteers on the POSPR methodology, land policies and the 2016 Peace Accord, as well as women’s land rights, and through community outreach activities. As a resident, people like Yudy can insert credibility into the activity and encourage an otherwise isolated community to formalize their property.

Inspiring Confidence

Volunteers are critical in strengthening the people’s confidence in land-related initiatives of the national government. Martha Leal also volunteered to work as the connection between her community and land formalization teams in Chaparral.

Thanks to the work of community volunteers such as Yudy and Martha, the government can achieve more community participation and social inclusion in rural land administration and formalization processes.

“It’s vital for rural people to be empowered on the topic of land tenure in order to understand the importance of having a registered land title. With a land title, they can access benefits such as loans or agriculture subsidies.”

-Martha Leal, community volunteer from the village of Betania in Chaparral.

Voices of the Social Leaders

Adela Méndez, smiling.“I am proof that women can also play this role. I have spread the message to the entire community, visited every farm, and ensured that everyone, including women, can participate and benefit from land formalization.” – Adela Méndez, Potrerito de Aguayo

“I became a community volunteer because I see that our rural community is vulnerable. They are not informed about the projects and the things happening outside of the countryside.” – Martha Leal, Betania.

Cross-posted from USAID Exposure

Sharing the Gold Medal Experience

A Gold Medal

a graphic of a gold medal for cacao of excellence This year at the Cacao of Excellence Awards, Colombian cacao beans garnered the world’s attention. Competing with more than 220 cacao samples from over 50 countries, Workakao, a farmer-owned cooperative based in Meta, was awarded a gold medal and shared the big stage with 18 of the world’s top cacao producers.

Wokakao’s criollo bean–the only Colombian sample awarded a medal–was described as “complex” but “mild”, a “creamy moderate cacao” that is well balanced with a “pleasant caramel note that lingers in the chocolatey long-lasting aftertaste.”

Chocolatey

liquid chocolate being spread on a metal slabWorkakao’s winning sample was the result of hard work to improve quality, yields, and processing through a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) that was facilitated by USAID in 2021. Motivated by the stakeholders of the PPP, Workakao has encouraged its 900+ cacao farming families to sell their “wet” cocoa beans to its collection center, enabling the cooperative to standardize post-harvest processing and achieve a consistently higher-quality bean after fermentation.

“The gold medal is the result of the work we have been doing with the support of PPP stakeholders and the cacao farmer field schools that taught us to apply the acquired knowledge on our farms,” said Leonel Murrillo, a member of Agroguamal, one of the cacao organizations under Workakao.”

a woman sorting through cacao beansIn the wake of the historic moment, USAID’s Land for Prosperity Activity wanted to take advantage of the momentum. Farmers under additional USAID-facilitated PPPs in the cacao value chain traveled around the country for multi-day experience-sharing workshops to learn more about how Workakao and Meta-based producers are improving cacao processing and marketing as well as how to improve the integration of youth and women into the value chain.

The 16 cacao organizations from Cauca, Meta, Norte de Santander, and Nariño met with key actors to share valuable experiences related to technical processes and management of the bean, operating farmer associations, training rural farmers across a large area, and finding niche export markets for quality aroma cacao. The farmers also shared their experiences with organic certification and environmentally-friendly farming models based on commitments to end deforestation.

“We were immensely happy because the gold medal represents the work of our entire cacao community. It also has injected us with strength and hard work, because the real commitment starts now. We need to be able to sustain the quality of our cacao and give our products an added value, so the benefits reach our communities well into the future.”

– Leonel Murillo, cacao farmer and member of the Workakao Cooperative, Meta, Colombia

The Women at the Heart of Cacao

“We have learned so much on this journey. We have learned that we need to prioritize quality in order to reach buyers willing to pay a better price. Workakao is an example for all of us to continue working towards that quality,” explained Arcelia Prieto, a cacao farmer in Norte de Santander and member of Asoprocanor (Association of Cacao Producers from Norte de Santander and Catatumbo).

Prieto joined the events to share her experience with the creation and promotion of the Women with a Heart of Cacao (Mujeres con Corazón Cacaotero) strategy, which has engaged 70 women producers from the conflictive region of Catatumbo, which is located in northeastern Colombia along the border with Venezuela. The empowerment strategy encourages the development of new capacities of women farmers, including technical skills to process and transform their cacao into final products like chocolate.

 

“What we have learned here with Workakao is that we have to start small, from the base, in order to be successful.”

– Arcelia Prieto, cacao farmer from Norte de Santander.

The women-led strategy also takes into account other aspects of their lives and business such as who will replace them and take over their cacao plantations. The long history of illicit economies in the region and the border with Venezuela have made it difficult to keep children safe and insulated from risky behavior and illegal activities. To confront this harsh reality, the women have incorporated their children into the cacao plantations to teach them essential farming techniques and how the bean is processed.

“As mothers, we all suffer as we watch our children fall victim to drug addiction or illegal activities. They are losing their childhood. So we have included our children to be part of the agribusiness. It’s important to show them from an early age. They are the future and have the potential to show the country that Catatumbo is not just a place for illicit economies.”

– Arcelia Prieto of Asoprocanor.

100 Years of Cacao

To understand how cacao can be a driving force of family integration, the women of Catatumbo need to look no further than the farm of Betsabeth Álvarez, a cacao legend in Colombian hailing from the municipality of Padilla, Cauca. Betsabeth celebrated her 101st birthday this year and is still participating, hand in hand with her family and community, in the marketing strategy of her now famous chocolate balls: Choculas.

“If you ask me, chocolate meets all your nutritional needs. It will make you strong and improve your memory. Look at me, this is life, and I am happy,” Betsabeth said.

Betsabeth started her life dedicated to cacao as a young child tending her grandparents’ and parents’ trees, who taught her how to process cacao with a mortar and pestle.

“My entire family is involved, my grandchildren, my nieces and nephews, everybody is part of it, and I hope they never let it disappear, because this is a beautiful tradition.”

In addition to cultivation and processing, the experience sharing events focus on land rights, women’s rights, and a better understanding of the care economy. Most of the women who work in land and agricultural activities also spend a large part of their time doing unpaid care work: such as caring for, feeding, and raising children, as well as activities that are vital for a healthy society, such as caring for the elderly and disabled.

“Being with women cacao farmers from other regions has allowed us to recognize, recover, and share ancestral knowledge that is in all of us. Afro-Colombian women have that feeling of being resilient to protect our communities.”

– Fanny Rodríguez, member of the cacao farming group from Rescate Las Varas, an Afro-Colombian community council in Tumaco, Nariño.

Rediscovering History

It is believed that cacao first grew in the Amazon basin and then spread north and south throughout the Americas, including to the Aztec and the Mayan civilizations, who developed successful processing techniques. For them, the plant was a symbol of wealth, and its beans were used as currency.

Today, cacao is grown primarily in tropical climates around the Equator. Approximately half of the world’s cacao comes from the Ivory Coast and Ghana in West Africa. Despite ideal climatic conditions for cacao cultivation, Colombia is not even in the top 10 cacao-producing countries. Low levels of education and aging cacao crops have limited small-scale cacao farmers productivity and earning potential.

A Future for Cacao in Colombia

In 2022, Colombia produced more than 62,000 metric tons of cacao beans, positioning it within the top 20. Unfortunately, Colombia’s cacao exports are minimal and the majority of what is produced is sold domestically. For now, this is one of the challenges that cacao producers like Workakao have solved.

Over the last four years, Land for Prosperity has facilitated the creation of seven PPPs related to the cacao value chain that include over 33,600 farmers, 41% of which are women. In many parts of Colombia, such as Tumaco’s Pacific coast and the mountains of Northern Cauca, women represent half of the workforce.

“USAID has been there for us since the beginning. They have helped us obtain training, they come to our farms to teach us about becoming organic farmers, and above all, they have helped us become visible to a market that did not exist before.”
– Enith Zanabria, cacao producer from Meta and member of Workakao cooperative.

Cross-posted from USAID Exposure

Requesting Land for their Culture

With USAID support, 7 indigenous Pijao communities in Tolima have applied with the government for communal landholdings to establish indigenous reserves.

The territory of their dreams

The Los Tambillos farm, located in the mountains of Southern Tolima, could become a reservation or a “dream territory” for a Pijao indigenous community in the municipality of Chaparral. People say that this 200 plus hectare farm was once the land of a group of Pijao ancestors called Los Tambillos.

Jose María Leal stands smiling
Jose María Leal is the ancestral guide of his community and he has played an important role throughout the process of identifying, negotiating, and applying for the role of his ancestors.

Today, the indigenous council of this community, called Ivanazka Lemanyá de Calarma, has presented the Los Tambillos farm to the Colombian government as an option to establish their reservation.

“We longed to have this land because we are focused on recovering ancestral knowledge, ancestral medicine, and medicinal plants. We want to recover all the species that are in this area to take care of them, preserve them and multiply them.”

– Jose María Leal, ancestral guide of this community.

a group of indigenous people stand performing a ceremonyWith the recent implementation of the Rural Property and Land Administration Plan (POSPR) in Chaparral, the Ivanazka Lemanyá de Calarma community is one of the seven Pijao indigenous groups who are submitting applications to the government to establish reservations. In total, the seven applications encompass 16 parcels covering 1,800 hectares.

POSPRs are an ongoing government strategy to untangle land use and administration issues and comply with the 2016 Peace Accords. The Land for Prosperity Activity, USAID’s biggest land tenure programming, is supporting these schemes to update the rural cadaster, formalize property and strengthen land administration in Colombia.

During the information collection process of the POSPR, the government now requires technical land experts to include indigenous communities with the goal of preserving their identities and protecting their land rights.

Ancestral Guides: Land Protectors

two indigenous men stand side by sideBefore working on the applications of the seven reservations, Land for Prosperity carried out Free, Prior, and Informed Consent sessions with 11 communities that represent more than 2,500 people. After giving their consent, each community elected an Ancestral Guide to act as a point of contact for all communication and harmonization between the communities and the team implementing the POSPR, which is backed by Colombia’s National Land Agency (ANT).

The network of Pijao ancestral guides is made up of four women and seven men, including José María Leal. One of the most important responsibilities of the ancestral guides is identifying possible parcels that could be used to request communal land.

The 16 parcels which were identified as ideal to establish indigenous reservations are all privately owned. The ancestral guides then coordinated their possible purchase with the owners.

a group of four men observing a parcel of land
With support from the Land for Prosperity Activity, the ancestral guides have accompanied the land formalization teams to carry out almost 700 visits to dozens of parcels and to negotiate with their owners

Some of the factors that they take into account when choosing the parcels are: their proximity to the community, the presence of water sources, the productivity of the land for agriculture, the presence of sacred sites, and the size of the parcel to build their communal and ritual spaces.

“As an ancestral guide I’ve had the opportunity to connect with other guides from other communities of the municipality to share our experiences. It is very gratifying to guarantee the security and protection of our land and to share knowledge with the community.”

– Marco Fidel Cuadro Vargas, governor and ancestral guide of the Matora de Maito indigenous community.

Ancestral guides are responsible for reaffirming and protecting the power and worldview of their communities and play a key role in guaranteeing that the protocols of their territory are respected.

A large group of people stand, smiling, next to a sign that reads "Programa Nuestra Tierra Próspera" An Opportunity for Indigenous Communities

As part of the implementation of the POSPRs, USAID has worked with 45 indigenous communities and 15 Afro-Colombian groups from six municipalities (Tumaco, Santander de Quilichao, El Carmen de Bolívar, Ataco, Chaparral and Puerto Lleras) to collect information and advance the necessary procedures to request collective land from the ANT.

“I see a great opportunity to make progress on the long-term objective of establishing the Pijao reservations in the municipality of Chaparral.”

– Andrés Mauricio Méndez, member of the Amoyá la Virginia indigenous community in Chaparral.

Cross-posted from USAID Exposure

Why Land Issues Matter in Rural and Urban Development

Municipal Land Offices throughout Colombia are providing local leaders with the tools to execute major development projects.

A Town with Encanto

The sleepy municipality of El Carmen was declared a National Heritage Site in 2005, but tourists did not start streaming in until 2016 when the government signed a Peace Accord with the FARC rebel group. Isolated in the lush mountains of Norte de Santander, the long-lasting conflict paradoxically served as a cushion to conserve its cobblestone streets and colonial houses, making it one of the country’s most authentic pueblos mágicos.

Now municipal leaders are following through on a strategy to give visitors a better taste of their town in a breathtaking setting by improving the town’s malecón and opening up trails to beautiful viewpoints like the Cerro de la Cruz and the Filo de la Virgen. The first step was to make sure the parcels were formalized as municipal property. The Municipal Land Office, created and supported by USAID Land for Prosperity, provided the municipality with the tools and skills to administer the land and process the municipal land titles. Once the properties were formalized, El Carmen mobilized over $830,000 USD to invest in the projects.

Over the last two years, El Carmen’s Municipal Land Office has played a noticeable role in the formalization and titling of public properties, including schools, a police station, and the site of a new hospital in the town of Guamalito, which lies 10 kilometers north of El Carmen. In 2023, municipal leaders took the first steps in executing a $3 million USD ($12 billion COP) project to establish the town’s first hospital, which will serve its population of more than 3,800 people.

For years, the residents of Guamalito and El Carmen had to travel two hours south to Ocaña to receive professional health care services. Last year, outgoing mayor, Wilfredo Gelvez, purchased a parcel neighboring the current health clinic in Guamalito as the hospital’s new home. But without the Municipal Land Office, administering the new piece of land would not have been so straightforward. In this case, the Municipal Land Office played a key role in managing the two parcels and transferring the land in the name of State-run Regional Noroccidental Abrego, which provides health services in El Carmen.

“This is all possible thanks to the coordination between the Municipal Land Office and the government land agencies in our region. The formalization of public properties allows leaders to finance infrastructure projects in areas of public interest like recreation, education, and community centers,” says Gelvez.

Facilitating Urban Development

These stories are indicative of how land tenure issues lie below many investments in essential public services and infrastructure in Colombia’s rural municipalities. In Santander de Quilichao, the largest municipality in Northern Cauca, a region known for land conflicts and violence, land informality rates hover above 50 percent. More than half of all parcels do not have registered land titles.

Santander de Quilichao’s Municipal Land Office was one of the first such offices established over a decade ago with USAID support. The Municipal Land Office is synonymous with urban planning and development. Thanks to secure land tenure administered through the office, Santander de Quilichao leveraged more than $12.5 million USD ($50,000 million COP) in investments over the last four years, more than any Municipal Land Office in Colombia.

Formal land markets discourage the illegal occupation of urban parcels and ultimately result in higher revenues from property taxes. The Municipal Land Office titled hundreds of urban parcels, including public properties like health clinics and schools as well as lands critical to public infrastructure like aqueducts and roads. Land titling has led to investments in a University of Cauca satellite campus, a SENA campus serving 1,500 students, a transportation terminal, and a hospital, among others.

“The Municipal Land Office has generated an important change in how we operate. Before, the issue of land ownership was the last thing we looked at and the reason that investment projects fell through. Now we initiate investment projects in the Land Office,” explains Santander de Quilichao’s mayor, Eduardo Grijalba.

Housing Opportunities

Recently, Santander de Quilichao’s Land Office and its 5 employees focused efforts on lifting a $3.5 million USD housing project off the ground. The Villa María housing complex, which is already connected to public services, is expected to provide a secure home for over 400 vulnerable families while providing a park and sports field for families. Santander de Quilichao’s Land Office already delivered the first 100 land titles to Villa María residents and expects to deliver the other 300 property titles in coming months.

In this case, secure land tenure enabled the municipality to provide dignified housing options and contribute to urban planning and growth in an organized manner. Perhaps most importantly, the Municipal Land Office, which is part of the Planning Secretary, provides residents a place to ask questions about land and property issues, fielding dozens of queries every day.

“People are no longer frustrated with contacting Bogotá or a lawyer to seek information about land formalization. We have a population with more opportunities and knowledge, and the Municipal Land Office has generated solutions for all,” says Mayor Grijalba.

A Successful Strategy

Since 2020, 42 USAID-supported Municipal and Regional Land Offices have helped local governments mobilize more than $87,000 million COP ($31.4 million USD) for investment in public spaces and infrastructure projects. The Land Offices have delivered over 6,800 land titles to families living in the urban areas of rural municipalities and formalized more than 500 public properties.