Finding a Way to Secure Land Rights

In 1959, the Colombian government passed legislation to create national forest reserves and protect its many natural resources. The law, known as the Ley Segunda, helped to establish several national parks and protect forests from illegal logging and mining. However, for local communities and municipal governments, the law has had a lesser-known consequence: the proliferation of an informal property market.

The entirety of the Santa Rosa del Sur municipality—located in Bolívar in Colombia’s Caribbean region—is protected as a part of the larger Magdalena Forest Reserve. A lack of clear land rights has not helped the municipality deal with activities like illegal gold mining and illicit cropping. Due to the municipality’s geography, only residents in urban areas are allowed to title their land and enjoy the benefits of formal land ownership.

Colombia lost more than 300,000 ha of natural forest in 2020, according to Global Forest Watch (Photo: Jair Beltrán Hernández)

Searching for Inspiration

An estimated half of the municipality’s population lives on rural land protected under Colombia’s forest reserve law. The other half—the urban half—does not face this obstacle and is allowed to process property titles for their parcels. Inspired by a USAID-supported municipal land office in nearby Ovejas, Mayor Mendoza also wants to take advantage of one of the few opportunities he has to increase legal property ownership in his municipality. By embedding a local land office in his administration, Mendoza can formalize public properties in the name of the municipality as well as private properties for urban residents.

“The forest reserves represent a major obstacle because we can’t formalize rural properties. And since we can’t formalize rural properties, we don’t have legality,” explains the mayor of Santa Rosa del Sur, Fabio Orlando Mendoza.

Over the last year, the USAID-funded Land for Prosperity Activity has coached Mendoza and his administration on how to set up the Santa Rosa del Sur Municipal Land Office. Although this municipality is not one of the Activity’s targets, USAID included it in its training sessions with other municipalities within the Montes de María region, providing the mayors with best practices. Mendoza’s first step was to hire the core team: a lawyer, social worker, and specialist in topography. With no financing from USAID, Mendoza rearranged the municipal budget and found a way to put the office together.

An effective local land office needs at least three key employees: legal, social, and cadaster experts.
“Other mayors need to understand that the budget will always be insufficient for a mayor of a municipality like ours, so it’s important to search for allies that can help develop your community.” —Fabio Orlando Mendoza, Mayor of Santa Rosa del Sur 

Delivering Land Titles

In August, the land office made history and delivered the first 19 property titles to families living in Santa Rosa del Sur’s urban center. Nine of the 19 families are registered as victims of the conflict, and 13 are women-headed households. Mendoza presided over a virtual ceremony in the municipal building and delivered the property titles to the new landowners, all wearing masks. In addition, his newly formed land formalization team titled 11 public properties including parks, recreation centers, and two schools.

“If we can help our residents access land titles, in time, the municipality can benefit from the property taxes. For these families, a property title means they can access credit, they can improve their homes, and they can strengthen their businesses,” explains Mendoza.
Santa Rosa del Sur titled 19 private properties and 11 public properties including parks, recreation centers, and two schools.
“If we’re all committed to our communities, then our main goal is seeing our municipality grow. And secure land tenure helps municipalities grow!”

Path of Self-Reliance

The mayor of Santa Rosa del Sur is not the first one to realize the benefits of a local land administration. Since 2016, USAID has supported more than a dozen municipal land offices that have delivered thousands of land titles, both public and private. In the Montes de Maria region (Sucre and Bolívar) there are three active Municipal Land Offices in Ovejas and San Jacinto (Sucre) and in Carmen de Bolívar (Bolívar).

Depending on the situation, USAID supports these offices with a combination of knowledge sharing, as well as financial and material support, to help them improve their capacities. However, as the concept spreads among Colombia’s rural municipalities that have never played a role in land administration, more and more mayors are seeing the opportunity to improve the lives of their residents while also increasing their tax base. For municipalities like Santa Rosa del Sur, USAID is less the implementer and more the coach.

Shifting local land policies

Mayor Mendoza continues encouraging his team and plans to deliver between 50 and 100 land titles every three months. Before his term ends in 2022, he hopes to have delivered a large portion of the 6,500 urban parcels in the municipality.

“After five years, we see a shift in the strategy. Today, more municipal leaders are interested in making the commitment to set up a local land office. In the end, they are the ones responsible for the whole process and not USAID,” says Carlos Martinez, regional director based in Montes de María, for the USAID Land for Prosperity Activity. “This is a great message for other mayors out there.”

 

Fabio Orlando Mendoza, Mayor of Santa Rosa del Sur
“We are confident. We are doing the awareness raising, the property surveys, and all the work with landowners ourselves. The families are motivated and happy, because this is the first time that they have seen this type of action in our municipality.”

This post originally appeared on USAID Land for Prosperity Exposure site

USAID Advancing Gender Norms Change for Increasing Women’s Land Rights

In recent years, countries around the world have adopted and strengthened laws that support women’s land rights, creating a foundation for greater gender equality. While this is good news, we know that women need more than laws and policies to fully realize their rights and have an equal say in decision-making about the management of land and natural resources. .

For many women, the ability to make decisions about land and natural resources depends on the support from their family and community. Whether a woman is a wife, a widow, a single daughter or a divorcee, her ability to benefit from legal rights to land in much of the world is influenced by the social norms, beliefs, and practices of  those around her.   

USAID is working to better understand and change social norms to empower women and increase gender equality in the land and resource governance sector. Recently, two of USAID’s land sector programs, Communications, Evidence, and Learning (CEL) and Integrated Land and Resource Governance (ILRG), completed a collaborative workshop on social and gender norms change. This was done in coordination with USAID’s Passages Project (2015-2021), which provides technical assistance and capacity building to projects that seek to understand the role of social norms in their programs.

The workshop tackled issues such as: (1) why social norms matter to achieving gender equality and women’s empowerment in the land sector; (2) why it is important to assess social norms at the outset of a project, and what are the best ways for doing this; (3) how to design social norms interventions; (4) how to measure normative shifts in complex environments; and (5) what are some of the ethical concerns and considerations related to social norms interventions.

Learnings from the workshop were recently published in a technical brief for USAID Missions and implementing partners: Gender Norms and Women’s Land Rights: How to Identify and Shift Harmful Gender Norms in the Context of Land and Natural Resources. The brief introduces key social norms concepts and tools to identify and shift harmful norms in the context of land and natural resources. It also provides resources for programs in the land and natural resource sector to better understand and identify gender norms, design and implement norms-shifting activities, and monitor shifts. The new resource provides practical guidance that helps  USAID, donors, and international development practitioners  grapple with this complex issue and improve the chances that land rights programs will incorporate effective normative change interventions that increase the support from women’s  families and communities when it comes to exercising rights to land.  

For more information on USAID’s work on women’s land rights, please visit www.land-links.org/gender-equality.

Three-way Collaboration among USAID Projects Passages, ILRG and CEL

The Passages Project seeks to build the evidence base and advance global knowledge and capacity for the design, implementation, and evaluation of norms-shifting approaches with an eye towards sustained and scalable programs.

The Integrated Land and Resource Governance (ILRG) program supports USAID Missions to implement activities to strengthen land rights, support inclusive land and resource governance, build resilient livelihoods and improve gender equality and women’s empowerment.

The Communications, Evidence and Learning (CEL) program provides USAID with an integrated approach to knowledge generation, dissemination, and applied best practices to strengthen land, urban, and local sustainability programming. CEL was awarded funds in 2019 to further design and implement field-based programming across five countries to generate evidence and work with local partners to strengthen women’s land rights under the Land Evidence for Economic Rights, Gender and Empowerment (LEVERAGE) activity.

Photo: Gabriel Chiposse and Lydia Wahiya, husband and wife in Namalapa Village, Mozambique. Credit: R. Singer for USAID ILRG

Working for a Healthy and Resilient Amazon

This blog was originally published on Climatelinks.

By USAID

According to the recently released Amazon Vision 2020 Report, USAID and its global partners improved the management and conditions of key landscapes in the Amazon, working on more than 48 million hectares, an area larger than Sweden. These programs keep forests standing, sequesters carbon, and reduces greenhouse gases. An estimated 38.5 million metric tons of carbon dioxide (CO2), or the equivalent of 4.4 million U.S. homes’ energy use for one year, were avoided, sequestered, or reduced as a result of U.S. Government sustainable landscapes programming.

USAID’s Amazon Vision unifies the Agency’s goals to combat deforestation, conserve biodiversity, create environmentally friendly economic opportunities, improve the management of important landscapes, and support Indigenous rights. The Amazon Vision 2020 Report describes the progress in achieving these goals and gives implementing partners and other members of the development community insight into USAID’s achievements in biodiversity and sustainable landscape initiatives across Brazil, Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, Guyana, and Suriname.

For years, environmental activists have referred to the Amazon rainforest as “the lungs of the Earth” for its ability to offset climate change. Because forests store CO2 above and below ground, they help regulate the greenhouse gasses that contribute to climate change when they are trapped in the atmosphere. The Amazon holds up to 140 billion tons of CO2, the equivalent of 14 decades worth of human emissions, and releases enough oxygen into the atmosphere to affect global weather patterns. However, its ability to mitigate global warming is decreasing.

Illegal deforestation is a key driver of global climate change. It threatens the Amazon and the communities who depend on the rainforest for survival. In 2020, an estimated 2 million hectares of primary forest loss occurred across the Amazon basin—an area the size of El Salvador.  In Peru, illegal mining has stripped areas of the Amazon of its vegetation and converted the land to bare stretches of sand dotted with pools of stagnant brown, often mercury-filled water.

The Amazon Vision 2020 Report looks at the Agency’s efforts to address this devastation. This includes USAID’s collaboration with Wake Forest University’s Center for Amazonian Scientific Innovation (CINCIA) to research how the effects of illegal deforestation in Madre de Dios, Peru can be mitigated and reversed. CINCIA scientists are researching reforestation techniques to reclaim the Amazon as quickly as possible, as well as monitoring mercury pollution and deforestation using drones. If CINCIA’s reforestation pilot with Peru’s National Protected Areas Services in Tambopata National Reserve is successful, the government of Peru could use similar techniques to reforest other areas of the Amazon, such as the nearly 10,000 hectares in southeastern Peru that have been destroyed by illegal mining since 1985.

Partnerships like these are part of a larger Agency strategy to support communities in the Amazon region. Moving forward, USAID will continue to build upon its investments in the Amazon to assist communities in shaping a better future. By continuing to work with countries and local actors, USAID and its partners can build upon the successes outlined in the Amazon Vision 2020 Report to scale promising interventions that achieve even greater results.

 

A Land Registry that Works for Everyone

USAID and Colombia’s Superintendence of Notary and Registry (SNR) continue recovering important land records by digitizing files and building the entity’s capacity to serve a healthy land market.

In 2016, when USAID tried to support the Colombian government with the digitization of rural land and property files, this initiative encountered resistance. In Cauca, for example, public servants opposed moving any physical land files off the premise. They locked and barricaded the doors, and when the files were finally loaded into a moving truck, they filmed the action and published videos on social media denouncing the “theft of Cauca’s land documents.”

In a country where issues of land ownership and access were at the heart of a six-decade conflict, the mistrust is understandable. Historically, a centralized land administration process has been carried out by a series of government agencies headquartered in the country’s capital of Bogotá. The Superintendence of Notaries and Registers (SNR) is the agency responsible for overseeing and protecting property in Colombia and houses the registry of all properties, including historical information about each parcel, including everything from who bought and sold a parcel to the mortgage used to purchase it.

Today, the SNR has 195 regional offices located throughout Colombia. In each office, millions of land documents rest in cardboard boxes, old filing cabinets, and mildew-filled basements. Each file represents a registered property, and some files include dozens of sheets of paper. In addition, there are more than 93,000 ledgers—large leather-bound books where regional superintendents, trained in calligraphy, wrote down information, such as liens, mortgages, and transactions, involving each parcel. The oldest of these ledgers date back to the 1870s.

Until the 21st century, none of this information was digitized or indexed in a central database. With the support of USAID programming, the SNR has digitized more than 5.5 million land files over the last ten years. Thanks to these efforts, approximately 30% of the country’s registered properties are now located in a digital database.

In 2020, under USAID’s Land for Prosperity Activity, the SNR began digitizing an additional 580,000 files from eight regional registry offices, representing 64 municipalities. By April 2021, all these files had been fumigated, boxed up, and transported to Bogotá. Managing the Registry’s archives is key to identifying property owners. Having this information secured, digitized, and indexed allows the SNR to refer to it at any time and optimizes the processes of selling or transferring the ownership of a property.

Digital land files help to reduce time to access and share data for land formalization and restitution processes while ensuring the integrity of land information and strengthening land governance at regional and national levels. The digital database allows the SNR to oversee and protect property for the public.

Regional SNR offices play a key role in creating and sustaining a functional land market. In addition to storing data, regional registries provide ownership and no-lien certificates that allow landowners to access financial instruments and government subsidies. Over the last decade, the SNR has also been a key agency involved in Colombia’s ongoing land restitution process by registering judicial orders to return land to legal owners.

With USAID support, the half-million files expect to be digitized and indexed in the SNR’s main database before the end of the year. These files include land documents from regional offices of Chaparral, Tolima; Cúcuta, Norte de Santander; and Tumaco, Nariño, as well as offices located in the departments of Córdoba, Meta, Sucre, and Bolívar. In each of these places, USAID is also assisting the municipal governments and the National Land Agency with land titling activities. The digitized archives help these processes immensely.

USAID is taking its support one step further and providing five regional registries with office equipment like computers, printers, air conditioners, and furniture to ensure the offices are properly organized for the arrival of incoming files. Part of the reason for this is in preparation for a series of massive formalization pilots that will significantly increase the SNR’s workload, adding thousands of registered properties to its database.

The SNR regional office of Chaparral, Tolima covers registered properties across five municipalities in the region and is home to 57,000 land files and 525 ledgers, some dating back to 1902.

Magda Paola Gutiérrez Vanegas, the office register in Chaparral, is preparing for two massive land formalization campaigns in the municipalities of Chaparral and Ataco. She estimates there could be up to 40,000 parcels in the office’s jurisdiction that will be part of the land titling sweeps. At the same time, Gutiérrez and her staff are working longer hours with the National Land Agency’s ongoing land titling activities, which have increased the Chaparral Property Registry Office’s workload from an average of 35 daily documents to 100.

Magda Paola Gutiérrez Vanegas, Registrar SNR’s Registration Office for Public Records in Chaparral. Photo credit: LFP for USAID

“The challenge to continue guaranteeing land tenure security is huge, and the effort is both physically and mentally taxing. Having all these municipalities in these development programs focused on land administration generates an avalanche of work for us that we hadn’t planned or budgeted for.”

-Magda Paola Gutiérrez Vanegas, Registrar, SNR’s Registration Office for Public Records in Chaparral

This blog is cross-posted from the Land for Prosperity exposure site

Zambia’s Chiefs Champion Gender Equality in Land and Natural Resource Governance

Originally published on the International Institute for Environment and Development blog.

Zambian land is governed through statutory and customary systems. Under the statutory system, the Zambian Constitution states that men and women have equal rights under the law, and the 2014 National Gender Policy gives traditional leaders a central role as champions of gender equality in their respective chiefdoms. These rights, however, do not extend to one of the most valuable assets that Zambia has: its land, and in particular customary land, which represents between 60 and 94% of the country’s land. Customary tenure is a form of land ownership that is communal in nature and held under the control of a traditional leader like a chief.

Women’s rights to inherit land, outlined in the Intestate Succession Act, do not apply to customary land in Zambia. This exclusion has profound implications for Zambian women, as customary land accounts for well over half of the country’s land mass. Cultural and traditional practices in many parts of the country further limit women’s access and ownership of land. As custodians of tradition, Zambia’s 288 chiefs have the power and authority to address the barriers that women face in land access, control, and ownership.

To strengthen the role of chiefs in addressing harmful gender norms and practices, promoting women’s rights to land, and increasing women’s participation in natural resource management, the USAID-funded Integrated Land and Resource Governance (ILRG) program has been partnering with chiefs in Zambia at both local and national levels to support and strengthen the role of traditional leaders to champion women’s land rights, bridging legal, policy, and gender norms to ensure sustainable management of land and natural resources. As discussed in this previous blog, the USAID ILRG program implemented a pilot initiative to engage Indunas – local advisors to chiefs – in a year-long dialogue focused on gender norms and women’s land rights.

At national level, USAID ILRG is working with the Zambia House of Chiefs, an institution that provides coordination and operational support to chiefs across the country, to develop a set of guidelines aimed at promoting gender equality and gender-responsive policies related to the management of land and natural resources in individual chiefdoms.

Chiefs champion gender equality in land and natural resources

Recognizing there was a gender equality gap in land and natural resource matters in the chiefdoms, two chiefs advocated for developing The Gender Guidelines for Traditional Leaders in Management of Natural Resources in the Chiefdoms, a tool to operationalize the gender equality mandate stated in the National Gender Policy.  In coordination with the Ministry of Chiefs and Traditional Affairs, the Ministry of Gender, and a non-governmental coordinating committee, a sub-committee of the House of Chiefs developed the tool to address knowledge gaps and provide practical guidance on promoting gender equality in the chiefdoms in the areas of land, forestry, wildlife, water, fisheries, and minerals.

It includes guidance on strengthening chiefdom policies and governance approaches, as well as addressing discriminatory gender norms and gender-based violence that hinder women’s participation and benefit sharing from land and natural resources.

Leading the charge to advance gender equality

“We know the problem, we see it every day, we understand the need and we did this to get to the solution. It’s our solution summarized on paper.” – Chief Kaputa

The Gender Guidelines helped chiefs recognize the value of ensuring gender equality in the management of land and natural resources in their chiefdoms. Chief Kaputa, who chaired the subcommittee responsible for the guidelines, explained, “We are not utilizing the potential of women in our chiefdoms, we want to do so but [cannot] unless we know how. That’s why our idea was to have the guidelines as a training tool for chiefs that teaches them how to get women [actively involved] in the development agenda.”

Developing the guidelines was a locally-driven initiative, which directly led to its success. Traditional leaders designed this initiative to address an issue that they had identified as undermining the development of their chiefdoms. Through their leadership and direct engagement, the initiative addressed the specific needs of their chiefdoms and leveraged existing relationships with key stakeholders.

Expected to officially launch in the coming months, the guidelines will be piloted in two chiefdoms through targeted implementation plans, including a coordinated approach to garner uptake by civil society organizations active in these chiefdoms. This pilot will provide a pathway for Zambia’s 288 chiefs to take concrete action to increase gender equality in the governance of customary land and strengthen women’s land rights.

“For many of the Royal Highnesses, it is difficult to address gender equality in the chiefdoms simply because they don’t know how to engage around the issue. These guidelines will make a huge difference… . The guidelines give us a plan and our role is to lead in its implementation and realize positive change in our chiefdoms.” – Chieftainess Muwezwa

About the author: Zenebech Mesfin is a Gender Assistant on the USAID Integrated Land and Resource Governance (ILRG) program. 

Popular New Radio Show Highlights Women’s Land Rights in Tanzania

By: Tasha Heidenrich, Landesa Tanzania

In July 2021, listeners tuned in to hear the debut radio broadcast entitled, “Mwanamke na Ardhi,” or “Women and Land,” a radio program on Nuru FM, a local station in the Iringa region of Tanzania. The radio program is supported by USAID’s Land Evidence for Economic Rights, Gender and Equality (LEVERAGE) activity, which focuses on strengthening women’s land rights and women’s access to credit in Tanzania. This particular radio activity is being implemented by local partner Landesa in Tanzania.

Although rural women in Tanzania have the same legal rights to land as men, they are not always aware of these rights. For example, women may not realize they have a right to be listed on land certificates along with their spouses; or, if they are the head of their household, to claim land certificates in their own names. In certain cases, local customs and harmful gender norms  discriminate against women and prevent them from realizing their land rights. 

To address these problems, the “Women and Land” radio program will be broadcast throughout Tanzania over the coming 10 months. Each month, the program will cover a new topic related to women’s land rights, ranging from exploring the rules related to inheriting property to women’s roles in governance. Each radio segment will be complemented by a live question and answer session to give listeners the opportunity to actively engage around the topic of women’s land rights.

National radio programming, which will cover the same topics in a condensed format, will begin this fall 2021. These programs will be broadcast on a national radio station that is popular with Tanzanian officials and other influencers. Many of the radio segments were developed in partnership with local representatives and officials to ensure that they are timely and relevant to local audiences. 

Why Women’s Land Rights?

Improving land rights for rural women can yield large benefits, not only for the women themselves, but also for their children, their community, and for the environment. Research shows that when women have stronger land rights, they invest more in their land, invest more in their children’s health and education, and use more sustainable farming methods that can increase both crop yields and household income.1,2,3,4 Importantly, some research also shows that women with clear, documented land rights are less likely to experience domestic violence.5,6  

By sharing information with rural Tanzanians, including those in leadership positions, about women’s land rights – while also trying to move the needle on the local practices that can stand in the way of women’s ability to exercise their legal rights – the radio program works to increase awareness about women’s land rights and improve the enabling environment for women’s land rights throughout Tanzania.

Why Radio?

Radio programming is an effective tool for education and behavior change in Tanzania as it is by far the most popular form of media throughout the country. It is made freely available to its audiences, has a wide reach that includes the country’s most remote areas, and is a popular source of news and information for men, women, and youth. In addition, radio is accessible to illiterate populations, and is a safe and practical way to communicate to the public during the COVID-19 pandemic. The interactive portion of the “Women and Land” radio program will directly engage its audience, bringing practical concerns to light, and make the information relevant and actionable.

By increasing Tanzanians’ knowledge about women’s land rights, “Women and Land” aims to help shift attitudes and behaviors around this important topic. By openly and widely disseminating information about the benefits that women, their families, and communities gain from women owning land in Tanzania, the radio program hopes to give women confidence to become more engaged in decision-making pertaining to land, and to encourage women, men, and local and national leadership to actively advocate for equitable land rights practices across Tanzania. 

***

LEVERAGE is administered under the USAID Communications, Evidence, and Learning project and is implementing programs, research, and evaluations to increase women’s land rights.

For more information on USAID’s work to advance gender equality and women’s empowerment in the land and resource governance sector, check out the new landing page on LandLinks.

References

1Ali, D.A., Deininger, K. and Goldstein, M., 2014. Environmental and gender impacts of land tenure regularization in Africa: Pilot evidence from Rwanda. Journal of Development Economics, 110, pp.262-275.

2Allendorf, K., 2007. Do women’s land rights promote empowerment and child health in Nepal?. World development, 35(11), pp.1975-1988.

3Bezabih, M., Holden, S. and Mannberg, A., 2016. The role of land certification in reducing gaps in productivity between male-and female-owned farms in rural Ethiopia. The Journal of Development Studies, 52(3), pp.360-376.

4Santos, F., 2014. Can microplots contribute to rural households’ food security? Evaluation of a gender sensitive land allocation program in West Bengal, India. GAAP Case Study.

5Grabe, S., 2015. Participation: Structural and relational power and Maasai women’s political subjectivity in Tanzania. Feminism & Psychology, 25(4), pp.528-548.

6Meinzen-Dick, R., Quisumbing, A., Doss, C. and Theis, S., 2019. Women’s land rights as a pathway to poverty reduction: Framework and review of available evidence. Agricultural Systems, 172, pp.72-82.

Securing Land Rights for Female Farmers in India

This post was originally published on Agrilinks.

By Thais Bessa, Integrated Land and Resource Governance (ILRG) Gender Advisor.

Purnima Kora is an ambitious farmer. She owns two small parcels of land that she purchased with her husband’s support and years of savings she earned from farming PepsiCo potatoes and rice, as well as by leveraging micro loans through a women’s self-help group. She also leases another half-acre plot to farm potatoes.

Kora is fortunate: Access to land is a critical obstacle to women farmers in West Bengal, especially those from certain tribes and castes. While government land distribution programs register land individually to women or jointly to wives and husbands, women still face significant legal and social barriers to obtaining land through other means, such as inheritance, purchase and leasing. With limited ownership, access and control of land, women are less likely to receive other productive resources and benefit from income derived from agriculture.

USAID-PepsiCo partnership is targeting female farmers like Kora to demonstrate that empowering women in the potato supply chain leads to better business performance and translates to improved revenue both for farming families and companies like PepsiCo. The program is using a combination of land literacy training, land leasing support and agronomic training to increase female farmers’ agency, productivity and income.

Implemented by the USAID ILRG program, the partnership’s land literacy training in land formalization and policy in India gives PepsiCo’s female farmers knowledge surrounding their rights as landowners and options for leasing land. Currently, only one of Kora’s two land plots is registered in her name. After receiving land literacy training, she plans to update the records on her second parcel in the public land registry. She now knows that updating the record will provide security, allow her to access additional governmental support services and help her to achieve her ambitions as a farmer.

USAID and PepsiCo are also supporting women’s self-help groups to lease land to grow potatoes independently. Over the past two years, women’s land leasing groups supported by the partnership joined the commercial potato value chain as PepsiCo suppliers, with production levels comparable to male farmers. Leasing land and farming as a group is attractive to women for economic reasons, as it mitigates risk and enables them to pool resources and skills to farm. Group farming is attractive for social reasons too, providing women with collective power to earn the trust of landowners and negotiate lease terms. Working as a group also helps women obtain support from family members and the community and offers physical safety when they are in the fields together.

Land access unlocks other productive resources 

Just as training alone may have limited impact in areas where women do not have access to land, access to land alone is not necessarily enough to empower female farmers. To support them to make the most of owning or leasing land, USAID and PepsiCo are providing female potato farmers with technical training on sustainable farming practices and potato agronomy — delivered by female agronomists — covering topics like land preparation, planting, safe use of agrochemicals, harvesting, sorting and grading and record keeping. So far, the program has supported nearly 1,200 female farmers, who have received this type of training and support for the first time.

Before the USAID-PepsiCo partnership, Kora had never received specialized agronomic training. She had learned everything she knew about farming through observation and practical experience. Now, she can combine her years of experience with technical knowledge for improved yields, lower potato rejection rates and greater adoption of sustainable farming practices.

“I know I can apply these lessons in my fields, especially in the areas of seed cutting, planting, irrigation and using pesticides cautiously,” she reflected. “The training has given me additional confidence to manage potato farming independently. That is why I urged other members of my women’s group to participate in the training.”

Leasing land and improving their farming skills has enabled women to formally enter and enhance their roles in the potato supply chain. As Kora says, “I manage the whole pursuit of potato farming by myself, and the decision on which land is to be farmed with which variety of potato is mine. I still consult with my husband when I feel the need, but I have the freedom to make the final call, which even involves hiring labor.”

Over the past two years, greater access to productive resources like land and information has increased women’s individual and collective agency, confidence, mobility, income, decision-making power and recognition as farmers by family and community members. In turn, this is increasing the farming supply base for PepsiCo, improving potato productivity and promoting the adoption of sustainable farming practices that contribute to USAID’s and PepsiCo’s climate change commitments, showing that women’s empowerment makes social, economic and environmental sense.

INRM Digest, August 2021: Gender equality and integrated programming

Understanding gender dynamics and the active participation of women in environmental and natural resource management is a critical part of effective development. A more strategic and intentional focus on gender equality can result in improved conflict management, enhanced governance and human rights, reduced poverty, and greater environmental sustainability. In this light, INRM considers gender equality foundational to effective integrated programming.

See below for some related updates from INRM and resources from across USAID and sector-wide that explore the interactions and linkages between gender and key development objectives.

In this digest:

INRM’s current gender equality work

  • Assessing gender disparities in fisheries and aquaculture
  • Including gender in the development of common indicators for HEARTH
  • Assessing the evidence of the benefits of inclusion on achieving democratic outcomes
  • Achieving gender integration in USAID environment programming

Additional USAID resources on gender and environment

Read more in the August digest here.

Increasing Women’s Access to Land through Public-Private Partnerships in Ghana

This blog was originally published on Agrilinks.

By Jenn Williamson

In Northern Ghana, women face many challenges accessing and owning land. Customary lands, which make up an estimated 80% of the country, are managed by traditional authorities and governed under cultural lineage and inheritance systems. In Northern Ghana, this system is largely patrilineal, which means that men receive exclusive rights to land and women have access to land mainly through male members of the family. Women’s access to land is, therefore, tied to their marriage and husband’s lineage.

Women’s lack of ownership and decision-making power over land has many negative impacts. Women who farm independently or raise crops in addition to their family’s acreage are often allocated plots of land that are less fertile and far from their homes. This adds significantly to female farmers’ time and work — particularly if it’s in addition to labor required to contribute to their husband’s or family’s farm — and places them at increased risk of violence as they travel between work and home. Because women remain the primary caregivers and are responsible for the majority of household labor, these additional time burdens also make it difficult for them to both farm and care for their families. Women’s access to land is also unstable, and they can lose access to land they have been living on or farming in the event of divorce or if the landowner — a husband, father or other male family member — passes away.

The Feed the Future Ghana Agricultural Development and Value Chain Enhancement (ADVANCE II) project noticed women’s challenges in accessing land and its impact on women’s livelihoods and empowerment during its start-of- project gender analysis. ADVANCE II supports the scaling up of agricultural investments in smallholder farmers to improve the competitiveness of the maize, rice and soybean value chains. An important part of this approach is to create sustainable opportunities for women within these value chains. This requires increasing women’s access to and control over not only finance, markets and information, but also land.

ADVANCE II adopted three strategies to improve women’s access to farmland:

  1. Using existing outgrower business — or contract farmer — networks in communities to influence traditional custodians to provide land to female farmers. Outgrower businesses, which provide services to smallholder farmers (also called outgrowers), take on the initiative of raising awareness about the economic opportunities for female farmers to produce and achieve high yields, making the business case for their inclusion.
  1. Collaborating with other Feed the Future projects, such as the Ghana Commercial Agricultural Project (GCAP), that award grants to outgrower businesses for land development. Through ADVANCE II’s collaboration with GCAP, over 40% of such land development grants were awarded to female producers.
  1. Working with local advocacy groups, such as the Coalition for the Development of Western Corridor of Northern Region (NORTHCODE), to convince traditional leaders and landowners in Northern Ghana to allocate acres of land to women.

Outgrower business owners were incredibly successful in advocating for women’s access to land. They built their case based on experience working with female farmers who were not only achieving high yields but also making reliable payments for services and inputs provided by the businesses. Nicholas Lambini, an outgrower business owner in the Chereponi District in the Northern Region, successfully negotiated with traditional authorities and husbands of female outgrowers to secure 500 acres of fertile land for 500 women to grow maize and soybeans by demonstrating how investment in women yields greater returns. In partnership with ADVANCE II, Opportunity International worked with outgrower business owner Yakubu Hussein in the Gushegu District in the Northern Region to help 23 female smallholder farmers acquire one acre of land each to cultivate soybeans. Abdul Rahaman Mohammed, an outgrower business owner in the Garu-Tempane District in the Upper East Region, convinced local chiefs and opinion leaders to release land for 100 women to cultivate rice.

ADVANCE II supported the efforts of outgrower business owners in a number of ways. It organized community sensitization meetings and advocated for women’s land access among male landlords, chiefs, husbands and female leaders in the community. As a result, leaders like Amidu Kala, an outgrower business owner in Fatchu in the Upper West Region, released five acres of farmland to five women; and Margerate Tablah, a farmer in Bussie in the Upper West Region, was granted 10 acres of her deceased husband’s land by his family.

“After the training, I decided to give two acres of land closer [to] home to my wife for her maize farm. Now I realize she gets home early from the farm to prepare my evening meals and takes care of our two children when they return from school,” says Mark Adams, an outgrower in Sawla-Tuna-Kalba District.

ADVANCE II also awarded grants to local advocacy organizations to conduct research and carry out initiatives designed to influence traditional leaders in favor of increasing women’s access to farmland. NORTHCODE, a local nongovernmental organization that operates in the Northern Region, collected data in four northern districts that showed that when women are given access to land far away from their homesteads, it negatively impacts their productivity. NORTHCODE shared its research findings during a regional stakeholders’ advocacy workshop in Tamale in the Northern Region, where stakeholders pledged their support to address the issue. The organization continued its advocacy work in 16 communities in four districts, resulting in leaders allocating 1,600 acres of land to 1,000 female farmers to produce rice, maize and soybeans.

“We are ready to hand over some of our fertile lands to our women and support them with inputs to farm… . If women have access to fertile lands for production, there will be a sustainable food supply and the nutritional benefits of our foods in our homes will be enhanced to reduce malnutrition among our children.” — Pledge made during an ADVANCE II forum on land for women by the Bussie chief in the Upper West Region

In addition, ADVANCE II facilitated district- and community-level dialogues in select communities in Northern Ghana, bringing together traditional leaders, women’s groups, landlords and youth groups to discuss the research findings and advocate for the release of farmland to women. Subsequently, draft memorandums of understanding (MOUs) were prepared and discussed with 16 traditional leaders, who then brought the MOUs to their respective councils of elders. Follow-up visits revealed that all 16 traditional leaders agreed to set aside parcels of land for land banking (aggregating parcels of land for future sale, development or farming) purposes. NORTHCODE organized district-level MOU signing ceremonies, where traditional leaders and landowners committed to provide land tenure rights for 1,600 acres of land to more than 1,000 women over a 10-year freehold lease period.

Overall, these strategies have led to over 3,000 women accessing more than 5,000 acres of land that they would not have otherwise. With more access to land, female farmers in Ghana and around the world could substantially increase food production and reduce hunger. With the stakes particularly high for ensuring food security in Ghana during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, women’s access to land offers immense potential. Closing this gender gap could mean boosting agricultural value chains and providing long-term benefits to farming households. As more women gain the same access to the land as their male counterparts, entire communities and markets stand to gain.

The “3 Rs” of Promoting Women’s Engagement in Food Systems

This blog was originally published on Agrilinks

By Chloe Bass

A discussion on sustainable food systems would be incomplete without attention to women’s contributions; yet too often they are a mere afterthought for policymakers, private sector strategists and international development program designers. While they may not be recognized, female producers, entrepreneurs and consumers make important contributions within food supply chains, food environments and food consumption domains of the world’s local food systems. Promoting women’s equitable engagement across all domains of a food system leads to increased food security, business profitability and country business profitability and country gross domestic product (GDP). As development practitioners, we must be intentional about including women and promoting their empowerment within all domains of the food system. The “3 Rs” Framework provides a useful lens for women’s integration.

R1: Recognize Women’s Roles in Food Systems

In many countries and contexts, women’s roles and contributions as producers, processors and consumers are underappreciated, and not formally recognized by policymakers and program designers. This can lead to exclusion from important training, planning, financing, decision-making and leadership roles. This can also have negative psychosocial effects on women. Across all food systems domains, when designing programming, it is critical that all actors — government, private sector, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and communities — recognize the roles women play. This means placing a premium on generating data, documenting women’s roles and communicating evidence of their impact within food systems. Women should be central to developing and sharing these narratives.

R2: Reinforce Women’s Access and Agency within Food Systems

For women to be economically empowered, they need to have both access and agency. Within food systems, this means having access to assets, capital, information and group membership. Agency is equally critical, as women need to have power to make decisions, to act on them and to be supported in the exercise of their agency. Reinforcing women’s access and agency are critical to empowerment and inclusive food systems.

For example, when considering ways to strengthen a local food environment (physical access to food, quality and presentation of food), governments can enforce existing laws and policies that support women’s equality, mobility and safety and ensure that accountability measures are in place, and NGOs can ensure that they design and implement programs that promote women’s participation and leadership.

It is also critical to reinforce women’s participation, promotion and leadership at multiple levels: at an individual level working directly with women; within households to promote female power; within communities and community institutions; within food and agriculture associations to levels of leadership and influence; and systemically through laws, policies and procedures. When this is done, it will benefit the whole system.

R3: Remove Barriers to Women’s Equitable Participation and Leadership

Reinforcing women’s current levels and types of participation within a local food system addresses questions of scale potential. These must be complemented by actions designed to increase the scope of women’s participation, including recognizing and addressing the most critical barriers to effective engagement for equitable participation and leadership. Within food systems, common barriers include:

  • Inequitable access to knowledge, influential networks, technology and training.
  • Inequitable laws and social norms around women’s ownership of land and other assets, women’s mobility, unpaid care work and household food consumption practices.
  • Prevalence of gender-based violence against women.
  • Blockages by gatekeepers.
  • Inequitable pay for women (impacting income available for food expenditures).
  • Barriers to women’s voice, decision-making and leadership.
  • Lack of women’s representation.

As this list is not exhaustive, conducting inclusive market assessments, gender equality and social inclusion (GESI) analyses or other surveys/formative research in the beginning of programming assists in identifying the critical barriers for women, especially as the intersection of varying points of marginalization and vulnerability (age, ethnicity, religion, marital status and sexual orientation) can compound upon one another. Once identified, the proper interventions can be set in place to remove the relevant barriers.

For example, in the domain of consumption, agribusinesses can create relevant products and marketing targeting women as a viable market segment and implement women in leadership pipelines and safe work standards. Private sector actors can also ensure they have equitable hiring, remuneration and mentorship practices. Likewise, industry associations and cooperatives serve a critical function in mentoring women historically excluded from enterprise ownership and contributing to agribusinesses maintaining the competitive edge. These organizations provide opportunities where women can be mentored through invaluable connections with people who are influential, knowledgeable and experienced in their respective markets. Continual learning to upgrade an enterprise while establishing relationships with gatekeepers of a market segment through association mentorship helps bridge the gap for women to lead resilient agribusinesses.

Ruth is a youth conservation champion in Kenya, who teaches her peers as well as some adults how to manage their land effectively in the midst of climate change. Photo Credit: World Vision

World Vision Example: the 3 Rs in Practice

In its USAID-funded Nobo Jatra program in Bangladesh, World Vision uses multiple approaches to address the drivers of food insecurity. To promote R1: Recognition, the program worked with 200,000 households and the local, regional and national government structures to promote improved nutrition in a sustainable way by recognizing the important role mothers and grandmothers have in food preparation, and working with them to better understand the health and nutritional needs of women of reproductive age and infants and young children. To promote R2: Reinforce, using our graduation model, that provided up to $188 in cash grants for start-up capital, World Vision coached/mentored 21,000 women in literacy, numeracy, financial management and skills needs for various trades, many of them within the local food system. In this area in southwest Bangladesh, previously only 15% of women participated in paid employment. On average, they earn $54 to $75 a month, a sizable amount in this area.

To Remove Barriers (R3) and address sociocultural drivers and inequitable gender norms in the production and nutrition domains, World Vision promoted more positive household relationships that improved the status of women in and out of homes. Men who think that women should be consulted on household budgeting and purchases rose from 43.3% to 79.6%, while those who think men and women should share household tasks rose from 8.3% to 53.5%. The project increased leadership opportunities for women to participate within influential community networks: food producer groups; village development committees; disaster management committees; water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) committees; and community clinic support groups (R1, R2 and R3).

Call to Action

There is a growing body of evidence demonstrating the benefits of including women in economies and food systems. The 3 Rs — recognize, reinforce and remove barriers — offer a practical lens to assist in the development of more equitable, sustainable food systems that benefit communities worldwide. Repeatedly, data show that including women’s involvement yields better household outcomes, increased idea and profitability and lower risk for businesses, and more representative government budgets and policies. We encourage all development stakeholders to examine where each might employ the 3 Rs in your food systems programming and how you might affirm other stakeholders who are employing these approaches. When food systems are more inclusive of women, we will see the rewards.